« Explaining podcasts using broadcasts | Main | MS City 1.0 »

May 27, 2005

JG Ballard's Top Ten Sci-Fi Films

As reported in Wednesday's Independent newspaper, JG Ballard's top ten:

1. Alphaville (Jean-Luc Godard, 1965)
2. Mad Max 2 (George Miller, 1981)
3. The Man Who Fell To Earth (Nicolas Roeg, 1976)
4. Dark Star (John Carpenter, 1974)
5. Barbarella (Roger Vadim, 1968)
6. Dr Strangelove (Stanley Kubrick, 1963)
7. Alien (Ridley Scott, 1979)
8. The Incredible Shrinking Man (Jack Arnold, 1957)
9. Close Encounters of the Third Kind (Steven Spielberg, 1977)
10. Solaris (Andrei Tarkovsky, 1972)

A good, if predictable, list. Funny there's no real 'inner space' movies in there (save Solaris?), given the author. Just thank god that S*** W*** nonsense isn't in it. Personally, I'd chuck The Day The Earth Caught Fire, La Jettée, 2001, Dawn of the Dead and a few more in there, probably at the expense of numbers 2, 5, 8 and 9, but such is the joy of lists.

Comments

Enemy Mine would definitely be at the top of my list! Enemy castaways on a strange planet, political and social commentary...what more could you ask for in a sci-fi film?

Is there more pretentious claptrap than Alphaville. I think not. Snoozeworthier a film is hard to find!

And La Jetee is an interesting formalist exercise, but not much of a movie.

And definitely not better than Mad Max 2 (or, as we Yanks call it, The Road Warrior).

And no Metropolis?

Blade Runner?

The Terminator? (Probably the best 80s sci-fi. The sequel doesn't even come close.)

Robocop?

Forbidden Planet (Creatures of the ID!)

What, no Bladerunner?

Alphaville - luverly, not surprising that Ballard loves it. Initially surprised at the absence of THX1138, but then perhaps it's too simplistic a narrative and takes itself too seriously. On rereading the list, it seems a tad underwhelming. Mad Max, Close Encounters? Solaris rather than Stalker? It ultimately emphasises that there should be a Ballard-based movie in this world (and I'm not talking about Empire Of The Sun). Tarkovsky himself might have done a decent job. Cheers, Colin.

I'm surprised there haven't been more Ballard film adaptations other than Crash and Empire of the Sun. I'd love to see a film version of High Rise (Amazon UK), (great analysis here), probably my fave Ballard story so far, and with arguably the greatest opening line in the whole of literature:

"Later, as he sat on his balcony eating the dog, Dr Robert Laing reflected on the unusual events that had taken place within this huge apartment building during the previous three months."

BBC 4 did a great adaptation, recently shown on BBC2, called Home, of the Ballard short story the Enormous Space, about a man, Gerald Ballantyne, who decides to see how long he can last without leaving the house.

All the familiar Ballardian tropes are here - the character thinly disguised alter-ego of Ballard, middle class, adulterous, and with mental instability, spatial anxiety, (sub)-urban angst and more gratuitous pet cuisine. Excellent, and with a terrific performance from Antony Sher as Ballantyne.

Someone should try making a film of Concrete Island (Amazon UK), a book which unfortunately couldn't live up to the promise of it's back cover blurb:

"A 35-year-old architect is driving home from his London office when his car swerves and crashes onto a traffic island lying below three converging motorways. Uninjured, he climbs the embankment to seek help, but no one will stop for him and he is trapped on the island, where he remains."

Oh this one could run and run.

Oi Merholz! J'adore Alphaville! 'Tis not snoozesome at all. It certainly has a different pace to the latest Vin Diesel flick, but that is A Good Thing, and in this context, pretension is probably a good thing too (not that that film is, really - you saying Godard is a 'pretender' when it comes to cinema?!). Likewise, La Jettée is a formalist experiment, yes, and therefore a great film, see?!

Good call RE Metropolis, though. Deffo. And I suppose Blade Runner would be up there, yes ... Though then Akira springs to mind, just in terms of a better evocation of an Eastern-influenced info-overload of a future city ...

As for Robocop, it's great fun with some smart touches but not exactly deeeeep. I'd rather have Sleeper in there!

Or Rollerball, maybe. Or Silent Running anyone? I'm tempted, somewhat mischievously, to suggest Jacques Tati's Mon Oncle and Playtime - in the scifi as 'stretched versions of now' definition.

Cheers Colin, and thanks Marty. I too would love to see High Rise filmed ... I guess the issue with filming Ballard is who, amongst today's directors, is talented enough to do a proper adaptation, rather than a simple filming of a screenplay? But agreed, that BBC4's version of Home was excellent. I'd love to see someone take on The Unlimited Dream Company, but christ knows how.

Ballard is certainly a big fan of La Jetée: he wrote an essay about it, which is in his User's Guide to the Millennium collection (I think there's also a similar list of his favourite sci-fi films in the book, but my copy's in storage at the moment, so can't check).

Proper adaptation? I still recall the feeling of disappointment experienced on seeing Cronenberg's Naked Lunch. I had so dreamed of something as structurally cataclysmic as the book. That audacity was singularly lacking, but perhaps inevitably so. There was another version of Lunch I seem to vaguely recall seeing which featured Ornette Coleman or am I mixing that up with some kind of film featuring his Chappaqua Suite? In my vague memory it was very self-indulgent b&w 60s claptrap. I'm whittering about Burroughs because of Marty's mention of Crash which I'd quite forgotten - probably for much the same reason. That let-down again of seeing such a fascinating book ill-served by a director one might hope would do better. I do think any proper version of Ballard - or Burroughs - would require a great directorial stylist. Someone with real guts and absolutely no regard for the box office... I loved those quotes from the books - they reveal the author's wonderful if bone-dry humour. Cheers, Colin.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Noted elsewhere

Donate!

Leave a tip

Tip Jar

Recent Comments

About this site

QR

  • qrcode

Advertisements

Job ads

Recent Photos

  • www.flickr.com

RECENT READING

  • Karen McCartney: Iconic Australian Houses: Three Decades of Domestic Architecture

    Karen McCartney: Iconic Australian Houses: Three Decades of Domestic Architecture
    Lovely book of modernist Australian architecture from 1950 to 1974. A coffee-table book but a wonderful one. Full notes here. (*****)

  • JG Ballard: Kingdom Come

    JG Ballard: Kingdom Come
    Ballard running on only one or two engines, but still chock full of wonderful ideas and observations, and with a few lines that will resonate forever. Curiously full of holes (no CCTV on the original crime?) but as a depiction of an England rotten to the core, timely and useful. (****)

  • Peter Jones: Ove Arup: Masterbuilder of the Twentieth Century

    Peter Jones: Ove Arup: Masterbuilder of the Twentieth Century
    Slightly haphazard biography of one of the great designers and leaders of the 20thC. The parts on building, design, organisation, context and practice are fascinating, and the portrait of Ove Arup himself is detailed and heartfelt. Some personal aspects are a little uneven and the writing is curiously disjointed in structure but it's a thoroughly good read overall, on one of the great thinkers and practitioners in architecture and engineering. (****)

  • Agustin Pérez Rubio: SANAA Houses: Kazuyo Sejima + Ryue Nishizawa

    Agustin Pérez Rubio: SANAA Houses: Kazuyo Sejima + Ryue Nishizawa
    Excellent book on the Japanese architecture firm. Full review here. (*****)

  • Nevil Shute: On the Beach

    Nevil Shute: On the Beach
    Absolutely fantastic read, if as thoroughly downbeat as a story about the end of the human race ought to be. Set in an Melbourne post-armageddon, as the last few people on earth live out their last months, it's a fascinating portrait of its time (1957) and Australia. (*****)

  • Elizabeth Farrelly: Blubberland: The Dangers of Happiness

    Elizabeth Farrelly: Blubberland: The Dangers of Happiness
    Architecture, urbanism, desire, happiness, beauty, obesity, greed, depression etc. A potent mix. A bit uneven, and journalistic in essence (which jars in this form) but good on Australia's architecture in particular, and with a beguiling speculative last chapter. (****)

  • Robert Hughes: Things I Didn't Know: A Memoir

    Robert Hughes: Things I Didn't Know: A Memoir
    Hughes is amongst the finest cultural critics and historians, and here focused on the first part of his own history and culture. So we get rich portraits of Australia, WW I and Vietnam, Italy, London, the 60s, art, food, sex, model aeroplanes &c as well as Mr. Hughes. Supreme writing applied to fascinating subject matter. (*****)

  • W.G. Sebald: The Rings of Saturn

    W.G. Sebald: The Rings of Saturn
    Jonathan Raban said "The finest book of long-distance mental travel that I've ever read" and I'm inclined to agree. A quietly majestic book, with peerless clear, evocative prose, drawn from immensely erudite research, and interspersed with simple ghostly photography. (*****)

  • Bruce Sterling: Shaping Things (Mediaworks Pamphlets)

    Bruce Sterling: Shaping Things (Mediaworks Pamphlets)
    A re-read, due to recent projects. Sterling, like the geeks he so admires, underestimates the richness of sensory information in the physical, when over-emphasising the new importance of the model, the map. The map has outgrown the territory only if you simply look at it. And yet there is no better guide to the map - of modeling, fabrication, the geoweb and arphids, and what this all means. Unlike most books in this field, it's as engagingly written as you'd expect and ultimately so thought-provoking and inspiring that you can forgive the oversight - which tends to come with, er, the territory. (*****)

  • Lebbeus Woods: War and Architecture (Pamphlet Architecture)

    Lebbeus Woods: War and Architecture (Pamphlet Architecture)
    Incredible radical response to the ruined Sarajevo. Must be read to comprehend the brilliance and bravery of his suggestions and visions, but essentially Woods suggests building in and around the 'scabs' and 'scars' of the shattered city, not simply in order to preserve or record history, but to also mitigate against further violence by creating a new heterarchical form of urban organisation. "Architecture must learn to transform the violence, even as violence knows how to transform the architecture." (*****)

  • David Peace: Tokyo Year Zero

    David Peace: Tokyo Year Zero
    Still dealing with this book. Reading this snapshot of a Tokyo in ruins, physically and psychologically, in 1947, after his shattering book on Brian Clough, feels like an odd change of gears initially. Yet the writing style - a kind of metronomic Ellroy-level intensity - pervades both, as does the startling ability to capture a sense of place and time. This is the more ambitious work, and may end up being one of the great modern evocations of Tokyo. (*****)

  • Peter Robb: Midnight in Sicily

    Peter Robb: Midnight in Sicily
    Perhaps the best book I've read in recent years, by Australian author Robb (see also 'A Death In Brazil') painting a portrait of southern Italy, filtered through history, food, literature, painting, architecture and principally the long-running legal cases against the Mafia. Absolutely extraordinary. (*****)

  • Geoff Dyer: Out of Sheer Rage: Wrestling With D.H. Lawrence

    Geoff Dyer: Out of Sheer Rage: Wrestling With D.H. Lawrence
    Genius. Only intermittently about Lawrence, and as much as Dyer's knees, childish Italians, Mexico, terrible Greeks, writing about place, horrible food, annoying English people, depression, travelling, and how dull Oxford is. One of the funniest books I've read, occasionally devastatingly sad, and also, accidentally/cleverly, brilliant on DH Lawrence. (*****)

  • Kerry William Purcell: Josef Muller-Brockmann

    Kerry William Purcell: Josef Muller-Brockmann
    Wonderfully detailed, carefully illustrated, and generally massive tome on the 20th century's greatest graphic designer. Essential. (*****)

  • Juhani Pallasmaa: The Eyes of the Skin: Architecture and the Senses

    Juhani Pallasmaa: The Eyes of the Skin: Architecture and the Senses
    One of those rare books that changes the way you think about everything. Already a huge influence, and one of the greatest books on architecture and urbanism that I've ever read. (*****)

  • Jun'ichiro Tanizaki: In Praise of Shadows

    Jun'ichiro Tanizaki: In Praise of Shadows
    A wonderful essay, from the early 20th century, on Japanese aesthetics. A perfect companion to Juhani Pallasmaa, but entirely pleasurable and enlightening on its own. (*****)

  • Christopher Woodward: In Ruins

    Christopher Woodward: In Ruins
    Unique book on the perception and understanding of ruins in western culture - specifically art history - by architectural historian Woodward. A bit too classically orientated - nothing on ruins in film, for instance - but some great stories and insights. (****)

  • Peter Carey: Wrong about Japan

    Peter Carey: Wrong about Japan
    Light (for Carey) but hugely enjoyable and interesting. Learnt few specifics - other than some interesting local insight on manga and anime - but gained a strong overall impression of Japan through Carey's eyes. (****)

  • Richard Williams: The Perfect 10

    Richard Williams: The Perfect 10
    Absolutely fantastic book on the great players in the most interesting, creative and challenging position in a football team. Puskas, Pele, Rivera, Mazzola, Netzer, Platini, Francescoli, Maradona, Baggio, Bergkamp, Zidane, all lovingly described by Williams. (*****)

  • Surveillance: Jonathan Raban

    Surveillance: Jonathan Raban
    I prefer Rabans's non-fiction - not that it's entirely 'non' - to his fiction, but he's such a good writer it's always entertaining and interesting. Ending a bit, well, open-ended - which is also interesting - but great, important themes here. (****)

Now playing

Recent Listening

  • Four Tet -

    Four Tet: Ringer
    An EP of 4 tracks, but a good size. Never mind the width though, feel the quality. Sidestepping his more abstract and Steve Reid-inflected recent work, Hebden delivers some beautifully pulsing techno, pilotis under a delicately arranged harmonic terrain. Fantastic stuff. (*****)

  • Themselves -

    Themselves: Them
    A few years after its release, I belatedly catch up with this album. A corker. Funny, lyrical and hugely enjoyable. (*****)

  • Goldmund -

    Goldmund: Two Point Discrimination
    Delicate, fragile and lovely. (*****)

  • Oren Ambarchi: Lost like a star
    The lad Ambarchi is one of the finest musicians around at the moment. Here, two long tracks of utterly gorgeous drone, with dynamics shifting from breathing to crashing, extracted from the guitar. Apparently available on vinyl, I picked up the mp3s from Boomkat.com (*****)
  • Burial: Untrue
    Believe the hype. At first 'glance' a perfectly reasonable but dated darkstep; with headphones on, another story. (****)
  • Klimek: Dedications
    Blurring analogue (esp. guitar) experimentation with digital, in the now time-honoured fashion. But quite lovely. Track titles give some sense of the mise-en-scéne: "for Zofia Klimek & Gregory Crewdson"; "for Jim Hall & Kurt Kirkwood"; "for Mark Hollis & Giacinto Scelsi"; "for Eugene Chadborne & Henry Kaiser"; "for Steven Speilberg & Azza El-Hassan" etc and so forth. (*****)
  • Atoms For Peace (Four Tet Remix)
    Thom Yorke: Atoms For Peace (Fourtet Remix) / Black Swan (Cristian Vogel Spare Parts Remix) / Black Swan (Vogel Bonus Beat Eraser Remix)
    The Four Tet mix of Atoms for Peace is quite the most beautiful thing I've heard for a while. Yorke's solo album wasn't all that, but this remix by Kieran is utterly gorgeous. The Cristian Vogel Spare Parts mix of Black Swan is top class too. (mp3s, exclusively available from Boomkat.com) (*****)
  • Wooden Shjips -

    Wooden Shjips: Wooden Shjips
    Can/Neu vs. psychedelia, with more than a touch of The Doors. Fear not, though, the vocals are a lesser concern than the searing guitar and metronomic Liebezeit rhythms. There's something absurd about this music emerging in 2007, but it's enjoyable absurd: like a long-lost The Mighty Boosh band. (*****)

  • The Whitest Boy Alive -

    The Whitest Boy Alive: Dreams
    Fantastic clipped sparse pop album from the great Erlend Øye, king of the convenient side project. Classy stuff. (*****)

  • Bruce Springsteen -

    Bruce Springsteen: Magic
    It's not all hybridised jazz and po-faced sound art round here you know. This is great stuff. Simply imagine you're Tony Soprano, thumping the steering wheel of his big black SUV as he smashes through red lights deep into the Jersey night. (****)

  • Bennie Maupin -

    Bennie Maupin: The Jewel in the Lotus
    Absolutely gorgeous album from 1974, just reissued by ECM (Herbie Hancock's only appearance on the label.) Beautiful tone-poems - a bit Zawinul - and fabulous understated playing. (*****)

  • The Necks: Townsville
    Of course, amazing and entrancing. A new live recording - from Feb 2007 at Thuringowa, Australia - by the world's most consistently brilliant band (?). No guitars or anything, as per their last ("Chemist"); just the familiar spiralling motifs, shimmering and floating, piano, bass, drums for 53 mins. (*****)
  • The North Sea -

    The North Sea: Exquisite Idols
    An album on free-folk label Type The North Sea is the recording name of Brad Rose, boss of associated free-folk label Digitalis Industries. It's great exploratory stuff, full of drones, banjos, odd percussion, tape manipulation and ambient noise, 15th century themes and 21st century formal experimentation. (*****)

  • Yuichiro Fujimoto -

    Yuichiro Fujimoto: Mountain Record
    Very pretty and gently experimental record, pitting Fujimoto's delicately angular musicianship against a) subtle digital manipulation, and b) ambient field recordings from a variety of locations. (****)

  • Dave Holland Quintet -

    Dave Holland Quintet: Extended Play: Live at Birdland
    Supreme modern jazz album by one of the best bands assembled in recent years, under direction of the legend Holland. Features the extraordinary Billy Kilson on drums, who is worth price of admission alone etc. etc. (*****)

  • Skallander -

    Skallander: Skallander
    Beautifully orchestrated pop album, in the avant-folky style that the TYPE label has defined (from a duo incl. Bevan Smith, who used to record sumptuous electronica as Aspen/Signer). Nice horns, smart arrangements, good songs. (****)

  • OOIOO -

    OOIOO: Taiga
    Quite brilliant, if quite insane, album from Japanese avant-pop band. Fantastic fun. (*****)

  • Stars of the Lid -

    Stars of the Lid: And Their Refinement of the Decline
    Absolutely beautiful. Almost too beautiful. One of the records of the year, for sure. (*****)

  • DJ Rupture: BTTB Hamburg Radio Show
    Fantastic mix from a couple of years ago, by DJ/Rupture: download it here (*****)
  • Nettle -

    Nettle: Build a Fort Set That on Fire
    Top stuff from DJ Rupture's band. Insistent jittery clattering rhythms kick the crap out of any notion of 'world music'. (*****)

Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 08/2003

Measuremap

Analytics